
Mince under a mash lid, and the leftovers reheat better than the first night.
Swaps that keep this dish what it is. The prices on this page are for the recipe as written.
Vegetarian
Plant-Based Cottage Pie
Brown the plant-based mince for only 4 to 5 minutes, then simmer for 10 minutes with 250 ml water instead of 400 ml, as it needs no time to tenderise.
Vegan
Plant-Based Cottage Pie
Brown the plant-based mince for only 4 to 5 minutes, then simmer for 10 minutes with 250 ml water instead of 400 ml; mash the potatoes with the olive oil and oat milk.
Gluten-free
Skip the flour when browning the mince; instead mix the cornflour with a little cold water and stir it in for the last 5 minutes of simmering.
Dairy-free
Swaps are suggestions — check labels if you are cooking for an allergy.
List price at each shop
Has every item
no items missing · £6.43 of food
£18.17
65% spare
no items missing · £7.88 of food · £1.45 more
£16.89
53% spare
no items missing · £8.98 of food · £2.55 more
£20.58
56% spare
Missing items
These totals leave part of the list out, so a lower one isn't a cheaper shop.
· £5.96 of food
£16.49
64% spare
No price at Asda for:
· £7.00 of food
£15.76
56% spare
No price at Tesco for:
£1.61a serve
£1.61 a serve, cheapest at Sainsbury's
About £6.43 of ingredients used for 4 serves.
£19.80 across 5 shops · all 11 items priced · £5.52 more for bigger packs, 74% spare for later
£6.43
no items missing
you'll pay £18.17 · 65% of it spare
£7.88
no items missing · £1.45 more
you'll pay £16.89 · 53% of it spare
£8.98
no items missing · £2.55 more
you'll pay £20.58 · 56% of it spare
£5.96
missing 1 item
you'll pay £16.49 · 64% of it spare
£7.00
missing 1 item
you'll pay £15.76 · 56% of it spare
Beef mince
£5.58/kg
need 600 g2 × JUST ESSENTIALS By ASDA Beef Mince 500 g£2.79closest match
Asda£5.58/kg£2.79·
Tesco£8.00/kg£6.00·
Morrisons£3.00·
Aldi UK£6.18/kg£3.09·
Sainsbury's£6.18/kg£3.09·
OcadoN/A
Potatoes
£0.66/kg
need 1 kgAsda British White Potatoes 2 kg£1.32closest match
Asda£0.66/kg£1.32·
Morrisons£0.99·
Tesco£0.90/kg£0.27·
Aldi UK£1.19·
Sainsbury's£0.75/kg£1.50·
OcadoN/A
Plain flour
£0.47/kg
need 30 gJUST ESSENTIALS By ASDA Just Essentials Plain Flour 1.5 kg£0.70closest match
Asda£0.47/kg£0.70·
Sainsbury's£0.90/kg£0.45·
Morrisons£0.53·
Aldi UK£0.70·
Tesco£0.47/kg£0.70·
OcadoN/A
Butter
£7.40/kg
need 40 gCowbelle British Salted Butter 250 g£1.85closest match
Aldi UK£7.40/kg£1.85·
Sainsbury's£7.50/kg£1.50·
Asda£7.50/kg£1.50·
Tesco£7.40/kg£1.85·
Morrisons£1.85·
OcadoN/A
Milk
£0.73/L
need 80 mlCowbelle Whole Milk 3.6% Fat 2.27 L£1.65closest match
Aldi UK£0.73/L£1.65·
Tesco£1.50/L£0.85·
Sainsbury's£3.40/L£0.85·
Asda£1.50/L£0.85·
Morrisons£0.95·
OcadoN/A
Olive oil
£5.30/L
need 20 mlSolesta Olive Oil 1 L£5.29closest match
Aldi UK£5.30/L£5.29·
Asda£10.92/L£2.73·
Sainsbury's£12.00/L£3.00·
Morrisons£3.00·
Tesco£12.40/L£3.10·
OcadoN/A

Carrots
£0.69/kg
need 200 g2 × Tesco Carrots Loose kg 159.42 g£0.11
Tesco£0.69/kg£0.11·
Aldi UK£0.44·
Sainsbury's£0.88/kg£0.44·
Asda£0.88/kg£0.44·
Morrisons£0.44·
OcadoN/A

Frozen peas
£1.28/kg
need 150 gGrower's Harvest Garden Peas 900 g£1.15closest match
Tesco£1.28/kg£1.15·
Morrisons£0.50·
Aldi UK£1.09·
Sainsbury's£1.70/kg£1.55·
Asda£4.59/kg£1.72·
OcadoN/A

Brown onion
£0.80/kg
need 150 gSainsbury's Onions 1 kg£0.80closest match
Sainsbury's£0.80/kg£0.80·
Tesco£0.95/kg£0.11·
Aldi UK£0.95·
Asda~£1.68/kg£0.95·
Morrisons£0.95·
OcadoN/A

Dried thyme
£43.33/kg
need 2 gStamford Street Co. Standard 15 g£0.65closest match
Sainsbury's£43.33/kg£0.65·
Aldi UK£0.65·
Morrisons£1.09·
TescoN/A·
AsdaN/A·
OcadoN/A

Tomato paste
£0.59
need 50 gMorrisons Tomato Puree ( ) 200 gclosest match
Morrisons£0.59·
Aldi UK£0.59·
Tesco£2.95/kg£0.59·
Asda£3.50/kg£0.70·
Sainsbury's£9.62/kg£1.25·
OcadoN/A